日本问题研究 ›› 2022, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (5): 47-61.DOI: 10.14156/j.cnki.rbwtyj.2022.05.005

• 江户儒学的复古思潮研究专题 • 上一篇    下一篇

德非性与性趋善 ——从德·性论探析伊藤仁斋古义学之返古开新

贾晰   

  1. 中国人民大学 哲学院,北京100872
  • 收稿日期:2022-06-13 发布日期:2022-12-21
  • 作者简介:贾晰,女,中国人民大学哲学博士,主要从事日本哲学、日本汉学研究。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金重大项目“日本朱子学文献编纂与研究”(17ZDA012)

Virtues NonNature and Good Tendency of Nature: An analysis of Ito Jinsais Kogigaku from the Perspective of VirtueVirtues NonNature and Good Tendency of Nature: An analysis of Ito Jinsais Kogigaku from the Perspective of Virtue

JIA Xi   

  1. School of Philosophy, Renmin University of China, Beijing, 100872, China
  • Received:2022-06-13 Published:2022-12-21

摘要: 东亚复古思潮中的代表人物伊藤仁斋,以自觉性批判的方式试图跨越朱子学而直返孔孟之道,创建了返古开新的古义学。位于古义学核心纲领“性道教”中的德·性论,在批判朱子学与会通孔孟方面别具一格。其反对宋儒将“德”训为“得于心”,而将之看作仁义礼智之总名,并与“道”之意涵相勾连,从而诠释出具有超越性、本体意味的“本然之德”;又批判宋儒以仁义礼智为性、将性分为气质之性与本然之性,以及将孟子之性善论看作性皆善的观点,而融贯孔子之“性相近”与孟子之“性善”,得出性具有“不齐”与“趋善”两个特征。由伊藤仁斋之德·性论,既可窥见其独特的古义学建构,亦可反思宋儒的理学建构。

关键词: 伊藤仁斋, 本然之德, 性善论, 古义学

Abstract: Ito Jinsai, a representative of East Asian retro trend of thought, tried to transcend Zhu Xi Doctrine and go straight back to the doctrines of Confucius and Mencius by means of selfconscious criticism, and established the theory of Kogigaku which reserves traditional culture and makes innovation. The theory of virtue, which is at the core of Kogigaku, is unique in criticizing Zhu Xi doctrine and integrating the thought of Confucius and Mencius. He objected to the Sung Confucianism preaching “virtue” as “from the heart”, and regarded it as the general name of benevolence, righteousness, propriety and wisdom, and linked it with the meaning of “Tao”, thus interpreting the transcendental and noumenal meaning of “natural virtue”. He also criticized Sung Confucianism for taking the four cardinal virtues as nature, dividing nature into temperamental and original nature, and regarding Mencius theory of the goodness of human nature as the view that all nature is good. On the contrary, he integrated Confucius concept of “similar nature” with Mencius theory of “the goodness of human nature”, and concluded that nature has two characteristics of “disharmony” and “tending to be good”. From Ito Jinsais theory of virtue, we can not only know his unique construction of Kogigaku, but also reflect on the neoConfucianism construction of Sung Confucianism.

Key words: Ito Jinsai, original virtue, theory of the goodness of human nature, Kogigaku

中图分类号: