日本问题研究 ›› 2023, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (5): 54-63.DOI: 10.14156/j.cnki.rbwtyj.2023.05.006

• 文化研究 • 上一篇    

鲁迅“国民性”批判的日本影响及其文化超越

郝雨1,郝丛丛2   

  1. 1上海大学 新闻传播学院,上海200444;2东京外国语大学 综合国际学研究科 ,东京1838534
  • 收稿日期:2023-01-29 发布日期:2023-12-20

Lu Xun’s Criticism of “National Character” and Its Japanese Influence and Cultural Transcendence

HAO Yu1, HAO Congcong2   

  1. 1School of Journalism and Communication, Shanghai University, Shanghai, 200444, China; 2Graduate School of Global Studies, Tokyo University of Foreign Studies, Tokyo, 1838534, Japan
  • Received:2023-01-29 Published:2023-12-20

摘要: 基于多年来关于鲁迅研究的文献资料,考察梳理了鲁迅从赴日求学,弃医从文,到“国民性”思想的产生,这一期间内所受到的种种影响,分析鲁迅提出的“国民性”与日本“国民性”的差别。根据史料可以得知鲁迅深深受到当时在日本国内的关于“国民性”研究的影响。而且,鲁迅对于“国民性”问题的关注,从源头上看,受日本文化的影响很大,尤其是在留日期间的日本文化氛围的浸染。至于芳贺矢一的《国民性十论》,更是启发了鲁迅的“国民性”概念的确立。鲁迅通过自己的消化改造,将包括国民性在内的新概念、新思想注入自己的作品,其国民性概念实际上是对芳贺矢一“国民性”的反用,也因此达到了对于日本“国民性”研究的超越。也就是说鲁迅对于“国民性”概念的使用,完全不是在芳贺矢一的原意上照搬,却恰恰是反其意而用之。由芳贺矢一的对其日本国民性的赞美,而根据当时中国实际的国民精神状况,对于我们民族的国民性进行了深刻的批判。今天,重新审视鲁迅当年所极力批判的“国民性”的来龙去脉,并以此作为今后进一步研究的起点,进行更加深入的学术发掘和探讨。

关键词: 鲁迅, 日本文化, 国民性, 溯源

Abstract: Based on the literature on Lu Xun research over the years, this paper examines the various influences that Lu Xun received during the period from his study in Japan, his abandonment of medicine and his turn to literature, to the emergence of his “national character” thought, and analyzes the differences between Lu Xun’s thoughts on Chinese “national character” and Japanese “national character”. According to historical materials, Lu Xun was deeply influenced by the research on “national character” in Japan at that time. Moreover, the origin of Lu Xun‘s attention to the issue of “national character” was to a large extent due to the influence from Japanese culture, especially from the Japanese cultural atmosphere during his stay in Japan. Yaichi Haga’s Kokuminsei Jyuronn (Ten Essays on National Character) especially inspired Lu Xun to establish his concept of “national character”. However, the reason why the title of this paper is “Lu Xun‘s Criticism of ‘National Character’ and Its Japanese Influence and Cultural Transcendence” is mainly because Lu Xun, through his own digestion and transformation, injected new concepts and new ideas, including “national character”, into his works. His concept of “national character” is actually an reverse use of Yaichi Haga’s thoughts on Japanese “national character”, thus achieving a transcendence of Japan‘s “national character” research. That is to say, Lu Xun’s use of the concept of “national character” was not a copy of Yaichi Haga‘s original meaning, but rather a reversal of it. From Yaichi Haga‘s praise of his Japanese “national character”, he made a profound criticism of our nation‘s “national character” based on the actual national spirit of our country at that time. Today, we reexamine the origin and development of Lu Xun’s fierce criticism of “national character”, and use it as a starting point for further research, and conduct more indepth academic exploration and discussion.

Key words: Lu Xun, Japanese culture, national character, tracing

中图分类号: